Murder Mystery Dinner Theater in Times Square, NYC
Speakeasy, Die Softly: an interactive 1920s murder mystery dinner show at Carmine’s
Welcome to the Lou Zar Speakeasy, where the drinks and clues are endlessly flowing.
Things are not as they first seem at this ‘legitimate Italian restaurant’. Behind the curtain lies an illegal speakeasy run by a mafia family and filled to the brim with seedy characters. With members of the mob in attendance at this mystery dinner, someone is bound to lose an eye… or even their life!
Don your best flapper dress, hop on the trolley, and head down to Carmine’s in Times Square for an exciting murder mystery dinner theater show that you’ll never forget.
Your Night at a Glance
Speakeasy, Die Softly is an interactive murder mystery dinner show at Carmine’s Italian Restaurant in Times Square, New York City. You enjoy a three-course, family-style Italian dinner while a 1920s mob mystery plays out around the tables. A few guests are cast as suspects, everyone else plays detective, and the whole room works to name the killer before the night ends.
- Where: Carmine’s, 200 W 44th St, in NYC’s Theater District
- How long: About 2 to 2.5 hours
- What’s included: A three-course dinner and the full show
- Tickets: $139.95 per person
- Best for: Date nights, birthdays, friend groups and adults looking for dinner and a show in New York
LOOKING FOR MORE DATES?
Ticket blocks are released every 4-6 weeks.
"Speakeasy, Die Softly" is ongoing, with no closing date currently announced.
GET TICKETS
Fri Nov 20, 7:00 pm
Sat Nov 21, 4:00 pm
Sat Nov 21, 8:00 pm
Sun Nov 22, 5:00 pm
Fri Nov 27, 7:00 pm
Sun Nov 29, 5:00 pm
Sun Dec 6, 5:00 pm
Mon Dec 21, 7:00 pm
Sat Dec 26, 4:00 pm
Sat Dec 26, 8:00 pm
Sun Dec 27, 4:00 pm
Sun Dec 27, 8:00 pm
Tue Dec 29, 7:00 pm
Fri Jan 1, 7:00 pm
Sat Jan 2, 4:00 pm
Sat Jan 2, 8:00 pm
For group sales, email us at shows@themurdermysterycompany.com
Box Office hours are from 9 AM - 5 PM ET Monday - Friday
What Guests and Critics Say About The Murder Mystery Company
The Murder Mystery Company, as seen on ABC’s “Shark Tank”, is proud to present their award-winning murder mystery dinner theater in New York City at Carmine’s Times Square, in the heart of the Theater District.
Meet a few of the (Un)usual Suspects
When you join us for a night of murder mystery dinner theater you’ll be accompanied by a variety of questionable characters. From mob boss Lou Zar to the songstress Lucy Morals, the night’s cast of characters is one you may want to familiarize yourself with.
CAST OF CHARACTERSCurious about what to expect at our murder mystery dinner theater?
Dive into an evening where suspense and immersive drama unfold with every course served. From the first act to the gripping conclusion, anticipate a night filled with intrigue and a challenge to uncover the murderer among you. A few guests are cast as suspects, everyone else plays detective, and the night ends with awards for Best Dressed, Best Actor or Actress, and Detective of the Night.
SEE WHAT TO EXPECTDinner and a Show in the Heart of the Theater District
Looking for dinner and a show in New York City? Speakeasy, Die Softly puts both at one table, a short walk from the Broadway theaters on 44th Street. It works well for a date night, a birthday dinner or a night out with friends. Celebrating? Let the cast know when you arrive, and they can give the guest of honor a shout-out.
Getting here is easy from anywhere in the city or from New Jersey. Carmine’s is near the Times Square 42nd Street subway station and the Port Authority Bus Terminal, with discounted parking nearby.
PLAN YOUR VISITGet on the list.
Would you like to catch dinner and a show near you in NYC? Sign up for our email list to receive updates about upcoming shows, other murder mystery events, and more.
